LIVE TRANSFERS
arrow_backBack to All Articles
visibility69 views•schedule9 min read

Mauricio Pochettino to Manchester United: A Move Years in the Making?

format_quote

Manchester United are closing in on Michael Carrick's departure, with Mauricio Pochettino emerging as the leading candidate. Could this finally be his moment at Old Trafford?

FS
Aamir Bakshi · FanScanrverified
Published Nov 10, 2026 • FanScanr Editorial Desk
𝕏in
Mauricio Pochettino to Manchester United: A Move Years in the Making?

Manchester United have been here before. Mauricio Pochettino has been linked with the Old Trafford job so many times over the years that his name has almost become a permanent fixture in the club's managerial rumour mill. Yet, despite the interest, the conversations and the repeated speculation, the Argentine has never quite made it to the United dugout.

With Michael Carrick's position under serious threat following United's disastrous start to the Premier League season, Pochettino has emerged as one of the leading candidates to replace him. 

There is a complication, of course. Pochettino signed a contract extension with the United States in August, committing himself to the national team until 2030. However, the agreement is understood to contain provisions that could allow him to leave for certain high-profile club jobs.

For United, this is a familiar name, but with potentially very different circumstances. They have admired Pochettino for years, but have repeatedly gone in another direction. With Carrick's future hanging in the balance, the opportunity to finally bring him to Old Trafford may have arrived.

Manchester United Have Been Here Before With Pochettino

Pochettino's association with Manchester United goes back to his successful spell at Tottenham. His work at Spurs made him one of Europe's most sought-after coaches, and United were among the clubs repeatedly linked with him.

Interest became particularly serious when José Mourinho's position was under scrutiny. Pochettino was seen as a potential long-term successor, but United eventually appointed Ole Gunnar Solskjær permanently after his successful spell as caretaker manager.

The Argentine's name resurfaced when United dismissed Solskjær in November 2021. Pochettino was then managing Paris Saint-Germain, and United considered him alongside several other candidates. By March 2022, the club had spoken to Erik ten Hag about the vacancy, with Pochettino also on the shortlist. Ten Hag ultimately got the job.

It was another near miss, although it is worth separating reported interest from an appointment that was ever formally agreed. Pochettino has been a serious candidate before, but United have never come this far with him.

The circumstances are different this time. He is no longer managing Tottenham or PSG, and his current role with the United States presents a contractual obstacle rather than the straightforward availability of a club manager.

Still, the attraction is obvious. Pochettino knows the Premier League, has managed at the highest level and has a history of building competitive teams without necessarily having the most expensive squad in the division. United have spent years looking for someone who can bring a clear identity to the team. He has done that before.

From Southampton to Tottenham: The Spell That Made Pochettino

Pochettino's reputation in England was built at Southampton. Appointed in January 2013, he quickly built a team that pressed aggressively, played with energy, and was ready to take on more established opponents.

Southampton finished eighth in his only full season, their best league position in a decade at the time. More importantly, several players developed significantly under him, including Luke Shaw, Adam Lallana and Morgan Schneiderlin.

That work earned him the Tottenham job in 2014, and at White Hart Lane, Pochettino reached the peak of his club management career.

He turned Spurs into genuine Premier League title contenders, finishing third in 2015-16 and second the following season. Harry Kane became one of Europe's most prolific strikers, Dele Alli flourished, and Tottenham developed a recognisable identity built around pressing, intensity and quick attacking transitions.

The 2018-19 Champions League run was the highlight. Tottenham reached their first European Cup final, producing a remarkable comeback against Ajax in the semi-finals before losing 2-0 to Liverpool in Madrid.

Pochettino left Tottenham in November 2019, but his work there remains the strongest argument in his favour. He had taken a talented side and made it competitive at the highest level without the spending power enjoyed by several of their rivals.

For United, that is an appealing proposition. The club needs more than another manager with a famous name. It needs someone who can improve players, establish a system, and make the team look like a coherent unit again.

PSG and Chelsea: Where the Pochettino Project Stumbled

His subsequent appointments have been, let’s say, more complicated.

Pochettino took over at Paris Saint-Germain in January 2021, inheriting a squad packed with elite talent. He won the Coupe de France in his first season and delivered the Ligue 1 title in 2021-22, alongside the Trophée des Champions.

Those are respectable achievements, but PSG's ambitions extended beyond domestic trophies. The club wanted the Champions League, and Pochettino could not deliver it. Manchester City eliminated them in the 2020-21 semi-finals, and they suffered a painful last-16 exit against Real Madrid the following season.

Managing a team of superstars also presented a different challenge to the one he had faced at Tottenham. PSG had the individual quality, but consistently getting the best out of the collective proved difficult. His spell ended in July 2022.

Chelsea offered another opportunity to return to the Premier League in 2023. He inherited a young and expensive squad that had finished 12th the previous season, and the campaign began with plenty of turbulence.

Signs of improvement emerged towards the end. Chelsea finished sixth, reached the League Cup final and secured European football, but the season was not without its problems. Injuries, inconsistent performances and questions about the club's sporting structure all contributed to a difficult campaign.

Pochettino left by mutual consent in May 2024 after just one season.

His time at Chelsea should not be dismissed as a complete failure, particularly given the state of the squad he inherited. But it raised a question Manchester United would need to consider: can he work effectively within a club structure where recruitment and decision-making are not entirely under his control?

That is no small detail at Old Trafford, where the relationship between managers and the football hierarchy has been a recurring problem for years now.

The United States Job Could Be the Biggest Obstacle

Pochettino's appointment as United States head coach in September 2024 was an interesting change of direction. He took charge with the 2026 World Cup on home soil as the main objective, and the federation subsequently committed to a longer-term project by extending his contract through 2030.

It was a significant show of faith. The new agreement also gave Pochettino and his staff a broader role in developing American football, extending beyond the senior national team.

There is no confirmed agreement with Manchester United, nor is there evidence that Pochettino has already decided to leave the United States. But his reported willingness to consider the job makes him a serious possibility.

Could Pochettino Be the Manager Manchester United Need?

The appeal is easy to understand. Pochettino's best teams have been energetic, aggressive and tactically organised. His Tottenham side were particularly effective at pressing opponents high up the pitch, winning possession and attacking quickly.

That sort of football would certainly be welcome at Old Trafford. Pochettino has a track record of improving players and giving teams a recognisable identity.

United cannot afford another appointment based solely on reputation. They need clarity in recruitment, a defined playing philosophy, and a manager with the authority to implement it.

United's problems did not begin with the latest run of results. Carrick's position has been under scrutiny for some time, and the concerns go beyond a few disappointing performances. 

Questions about his tactical approach, the team's defensive organisation, and his ability to get a response from the players have been building for weeks. The recent struggles have only brought them into sharper focus.

A wider pattern is emerging, too. United's managerial uncertainty is part of a Premier League season in which several clubs are already questioning whether their current managers are the right people to take them forward. But at Old Trafford, the stakes are considerably higher. Another managerial appointment is approaching, and the club is reaching a point where it cannot afford to get it wrong again.

Who Else Could Replace Michael Carrick?

Pochettino is not the only candidate being discussed, and United are understood to have explored other possibilities.

Eddie Howe is among the names mentioned. The former Newcastle manager has a strong Premier League record, built competitive sides at Bournemouth and Newcastle, and has experience developing players. His availability makes him an obvious alternative.

Julian Nagelsmann is another candidate with admirers at Old Trafford. The German has managed Bayern Munich and the national team, and is regarded as one of the more tactically sophisticated coaches of his generation. His next move would be ambitious, although his availability and willingness to take the job remain in question.

Antonio Conte has also been linked with the position, with reports suggesting he is keen on the opportunity. His trophy-winning record is beyond question, but his demanding approach and history of clashes with club hierarchies would make him a rather different proposition.

For now, Pochettino appears to be the name attracting the most attention. That he is reportedly open to the move, combined with United's long-standing interest, makes this one of the more intriguing managerial developments at Old Trafford in recent years.

Could This Finally Be Pochettino's Moment at Old Trafford?

Manchester United have considered Pochettino before, but the timing has never quite worked. He was at Tottenham when the first wave of interest emerged, at PSG when United revisited the possibility, and then Chelsea before taking charge of the United States.

Now, with Carrick's position under serious threat, the circumstances may finally be aligning, and the noise is unexpectedly getting louder from all ends. 

The situation has moved considerably in the last 24 hours. Ben Jacobs, reporting exclusively for talkSPORT, says Sir Jim Ratcliffe is expected to lead a meeting in Monaco, where Michael Carrick's departure is likely to be confirmed. Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox are expected to formally present their recommendation to part ways with the current manager, with Pochettino emerging as the leading contender to replace him.

Carrick, meanwhile, is expected to return to Carrington as he waits for official communication from the club. The report also says Pochettino has a release clause in his United States contract, which could make negotiations much easier for United.

For the latest articles, transfer stories, and fan mood, visit FanScanr. 


Enjoyed this analysis?
boltLive Fan Mood Intelligence

Track 24/7 Supporter Sentiment Across Every Premier League Club

Explore Fan Mood Index (FMI), Delusion Score, Terrace Banter, and AI match predictions updated round-the-clock from real supporters.

Pochettino to Manchester United: Carrick's Replacement? | FanScanr AI