LIVE TRANSFERS
arrow_backBack to All Articles
visibility126 views•schedule9 min read

Manchester City Crisis: Have Their Players Given Up?

format_quote

Manchester City look broken, short of fight and increasingly lost. Have the players already given up with all the 115 charges noise in the background?

FS
Aamir Bakshi · FanScanrverified
Published Nov 9, 2026 • FanScanr Editorial Desk
𝕏in
 Manchester City Crisis: Have Their Players Given Up?

Manchester City have spent years making the rest of English football miserable. They have turned winning into a habit, made title races feel predictable and built a squad capable of overwhelming almost anyone. 

Yet how fast time changes everything. Now, after Pep’s departure and a few weeks of new-manager bounce, they look slow, fragile, disjointed, and at times completely uninterested in the fight.

Their 3-1 defeat at Nottingham Forest was another miserable afternoon for Enzo Maresca. Forest had not scored at home in the Premier League this season, yet they put three past City without dominating possession or producing anything extraordinary. 

Jair Cunha punished Josko Gvardiol's mistake, Liam Delap exposed the midfield and defence with two ruthless finishes, and Rayan Cherki's brief attempt to rescue the game proved little more than a temporary interruption to City's misery.

This was City's third consecutive Premier League defeat, following losses against Aston Villa and Brighton. They had started the campaign with seven straight victories. Now they are six points behind Arsenal, and the sense of revitalisation is gone.

But a bigger question hangs over the club. With the independent commission finding Manchester City guilty of serious financial-rule breaches and the club now appealing that verdict, are the players beginning to feel that nothing they achieve on the pitch will matter? Is the uncertainty around the club draining motivation from the dressing room? Or are we simply watching an expensive rebuild that has gone badly wrong?

Either explanation makes for grim reading for City supporters. The possibility that both are happening at once is even worse.

Nottingham Forest Made Manchester City Look Spineless

Forest did not need to play an extraordinary game to beat City, which was the most telling point of their defeat. They needed to compete, attack the spaces City left behind and take advantage of a team that looked completely unprepared for a physical contest.

The opening goal was a gift. Cunha dispossessed Gvardiol, drove forward, and finished past Gianluigi Donnarumma. Twelve minutes later, Xaver Schlager beat Elliot Anderson to a loose ball in midfield and sent Delap racing through from inside his own half. Marc Guéhi failed to get close enough, and the former City striker finished emphatically.

City were two goals down inside 18 minutes. It was their earliest two-goal deficit in a Premier League match since November 2019.

Cherki produced a wonderful half-volley to give City a lifeline shortly after half-time. They had 78% possession, 12 shots and 33 touches in Forest's penalty area. Yet they still managed only four shots on target. Forest had 11 attempts, five on target and, crucially, three goals.

Delap's second goal in the 73rd minute was the knockout blow. Morgan Gibbs-White found him in transition, and the striker finished into the top corner. City had been caught out again, and Forest had punished them again.

Maresca did not hide behind excuses afterwards. He admitted City failed to match Forest's intensity, lost too many duels, and conceded the second and third goals through almost identical transition situations. That is a damning assessment of a team with City's resources.

A Manchester City side should not be made to look this amateur by a Forest team that had gone into the match without a home league goal all season. Yet here we are.

Have Manchester City's Players Already Checked Out?

City's problems are not limited to poor defending or a midfield that cannot control games. The team shows a visible lack of conviction. Players are losing individual battles, making careless decisions and struggling to respond when the opposition puts them under pressure.

It is tempting to wonder whether the situation surrounding the club is beginning to affect the players.

The independent commission's findings have changed the conversation around Manchester City. The commission found the club guilty of serious financial-rule breaches covering a nine-season period, including the use of sham commercial agreements, misstated accounts and breaches of spending limits. City have rejected the findings and lodged an appeal. The process is not finished, and the sanctions have not yet been announced.

That uncertainty is now part of the club's reality. Every result, every trophy and every achievement will inevitably be discussed against the backdrop of the case. Rival supporters will continue to question the legitimacy of City's success, while the club attempts to defend its position through the appeal process.

Could that be affecting the dressing room?

It is a fair question, even if there is no evidence that the players have deliberately downed tools. Footballers are professionals, and they are still competing for trophies, contracts, places in national teams and their own reputations. But motivation is not always as simple as turning up and collecting a wage.

There is a difference between knowing you have a difficult season ahead and feeling that the club's future is beyond your control. If the players believe that sanctions could fundamentally alter the club's direction, it is reasonable to ask whether that uncertainty has started to seep into performances.

City's Midfield Has Become a Complete Shambles

The midfield is perhaps the clearest example of how badly things have unravelled.

Anderson is being asked to cover an enormous amount of ground, operating as the defensive screen while also being expected to contribute to City's build-up and attacking play. That is a demanding role even for an established specialist. 

Fernández has struggled to offer the control and defensive security City needs. Cherki has moments of brilliance, as his goal against Forest demonstrated, but his influence can disappear for long stretches. A player with his technical ability should dictate more games, not leave City hoping for one inspired contribution every few appearances.

Forest understood exactly where to hurt them. Schlager won the important battle before Delap's first goal, while Gibbs-White and Delap exploited the space in transition for the third. City had plenty of the ball but little control over the moments that mattered.

That is a serious structural problem. Anderson cannot be expected to put out every fire while Fernández and Cherki operate without sufficient protection. Maresca needs to find a midfield combination that can defend, progress the ball and compete physically. At present, City look short in all three departments.

City's Defence Looks Like It Has Forgotten How to Defend

Where to begin?

Gvardiol was responsible for the mistake that allowed Forest to open the scoring. Guéhi was too passive when Delap ran through for the second. Dias looked disinterested, while Khusanov's deployment at right-back did little to settle a defence that already appeared short of confidence.

Donnarumma is also facing increasing scrutiny. The Italian has endured a difficult spell, and the first two goals raised questions about his positioning and reactions. The third was an excellent finish from Delap, but the goalkeeper cannot escape criticism for the wider defensive instability.

City's big concern right now is that this isn't one defender or the goalie having a bad afternoon. It is a collection of players who look uncertain about their responsibilities. Dias and Gvardiol have been central to City's success in recent years, while Guéhi arrived with a reputation that suggested he would strengthen the defence. Yet the unit is looking increasingly vulnerable.

The Summer Spending Has Left City With More Questions Than Answers

City have spent heavily to refresh the squad, but the results don't match the investment.

Criticism of Fernández and Donnarumma has become hard to avoid. Both arrived with high expectations, yet neither has consistently delivered the performance needed to improve this team. Anderson is being asked to do too much, Cherki remains frustratingly inconsistent, and the defensive recruitment has not produced the security City expected.

There is also the question of attacking balance.

Semenyo's presence offered City a different dimension, bringing direct running, physicality and an ability to stretch defences. His absence has made the attack look more predictable, although it would be simplistic to blame the wider collapse on one injured player. City should have enough quality to function without him.

The bigger issue is that the squad does not look particularly well balanced. 

That is as much a recruitment problem as a coaching problem. Spending money is not the same as building a coherent team. City have assembled plenty of expensive talent, but the current mix isn't working.

Is Maresca Losing Control of a Dressing Room That Has Stopped Believing?

Maresca has a responsibility to find answers, and the Forest defeat raised serious questions about his team's preparation.

His players were second best in the opening half, and the same vulnerabilities appeared again after the break. The substitutions at half-time brought some improvement, but City still conceded a third goal through a transition that should have been dealt with far better.

The manager admitted that he needed to understand why his team had lacked intensity. He also insisted there was no need to panic, pointing to the contrast between City's opening seven victories and their three consecutive defeats.

But the concern is not simply the results. It is how City are losing.

They are being beaten in individual battles, exposed in midfield and punished by teams that have worked out how to disrupt their rhythm. 

There is no proof that the dressing room has turned against Maresca, or that the players have stopped caring. But the manager needs to restore some conviction quickly. Otherwise, the suspicion that this group has mentally checked out will only grow louder.

Manchester City Have Run Out of Excuses

Manchester City have too much talent to look this ordinary. They have spent too much money, recruited too many established players and enjoyed too much recent success for three consecutive defeats to be dismissed as a minor wobble.

Perhaps the players are simply suffering a bad run of form. Perhaps the rebuild has been poorly balanced, the tactics are not working, and confidence has evaporated. Or perhaps the uncertainty surrounding the club is having an effect that nobody inside the dressing room is prepared to discuss publicly.

Whatever the explanation, City currently look like a team without a clear identity or the appetite to fight their way out of trouble.

The question is no longer whether Manchester City can win football matches. They have the talent to do that. The question is whether this group still has the desire, conviction, and togetherness to make the season count.

Right now, the evidence is not encouraging.

For the latest articles, transfer stories, and fan mood, visit FanScanr. 


Enjoyed this analysis?
boltLive Fan Mood Intelligence

Track 24/7 Supporter Sentiment Across Every Premier League Club

Explore Fan Mood Index (FMI), Delusion Score, Terrace Banter, and AI match predictions updated round-the-clock from real supporters.